Introduction
Policy can shape new practice or codify current practice to guide future practice. In this regard, Mays (2020) points to the work of Rizvi and Lingard (2010), who indicate there is no single agreement on what a policy is or should be or how it should be constituted; however, their review of the literature suggests the following important considerations for what policy should:
- indicates what a government chooses to do or not to do; in some contexts, the absence of policy could be construed as an expression of a policy position.
- delineates a field of activity — e.g., distance education or ODL or open schooling.
- refers to the actions and positions taken by the state regarding a selected range of providers.
- is normative, indicating both ends or intents and means or actions to influence practice.
- refers to things that can be achieved in areas over which authority can be exercised.
- exists as a text that can be accessed and debated; but
- evolves from a process that is often contested and subject to review; and therefore
- is subject to ongoing modification in the process of implementation and in response to changing contexts.
- is mediated in practice by providers; and so
- is part of an ongoing discourse; and
- is usually located within a collection of related policies; and
- is increasingly influenced by global rather than just national perspectives.
As Strauss and Borenstein (2015) observe, policy can sometimes have unintended consequences — in the case of Brazil, for example, a deregulation policy led to a massive growth in low-quality private provision in a few disciplinary areas requiring minimal investment in infrastructure. With respect to private cross-border provision, or collaborative provision, of new possibilities such as MOOCs, Rambe and Moeti (2016) caution against wholesale adoption of programmes developed elsewhere and posit the need to allow for at least some adaptation to context. Policy and planning therefore go together, and the authors suggest that systems dynamics modelling could be a useful way to explore the possible impact of policy and planning decisions.
An initial search for “distance” policies yielded several institutional policies and policy statements but relatively few at the government or state level, and even fewer at the schooling level, outside of the open schools and open universities with which COL has previously engaged. As Makoe (2018) observes, there may well be mention of the potential of ODL in more general educational policy documents, but this is seldom carried over into the development of distinct national ODL policy and planning frameworks.
Many institutions now offer one or more courses using distance education, blended learning or online methods, sometimes in the absence of any national or institutional policy. Where national policies exist, they are not necessarily available in a digital format online, and some have not been updated in several years. Sometimes, issues related to ODL provision are embedded in other policy documents — e.g., ICT policies or education sector plans (please see Appendices 1 and 2, which provide examples of the evolving nature of ODL policy and practice in Malaysia and South Africa).
This document includes examples of available policies that could inform new policy development in countries where a policy framework currently does not exist or needs to be updated. Appendix 3 contains links to several of COL’s policy resources that might prove useful.
We can also learn from existing practice. Several open schools and open universities in the Commonwealth offer access even for learners without formal qualifications. There are also increasing numbers of dual-mode providers.
As Mishra (2021) argues, formal ODL practice involves a concerted commitment and conscious decision to use distance education. The listings here therefore focus only on institutions and organisations that have formally adopted such methods for all or some of their provision.
Africa
Botswana
Policy
Practice
Schooling
University
- Botswana Open University (ODL mode): https://www.bou.ac.bw
BOU Policies (see OER Policy, November 2019; Strategy for Technology Enhanced Learning, Teaching, Assessment and Student Support, September 2019; Learning Analytics Policy, June 2019; the BOU E-Tutor Model, September 2020).
- University of Botswana (Dual Mode) – Distance Education: https://www.ub.bw/study/distance-education
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/botswana
Cameroon
Policy
Practice
Public institutions offering one or more distance/online courses, often in partnership with external institutions:
Private institutions:
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/cameroon
Eswatini
Policy
Practice
Schooling
- Emlalatini Development Centre
University
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/eswatini
The Gambia
Policy
Practice
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/gambia
Ghana
Policy
Practice
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/ghana
Kenya
Policy
Practice
Schooling
University
All of the following universities offer some distance education/online learning:
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/kenya
Lesotho
Policy
Practice
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/lesotho
Malawi
Policy
Practice
Schooling
University
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/malawi
Mauritius
Policy
Practice
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/mauritius
Mozambique
Policy:
- Mozambique has a Distance Learning Strategy 2013–2018. The strategy is to be evaluated and used to guide the development of a new strategy.
- There is a Distance Learning Regulation, which was approved by the Council of Ministers, Decree Number 35/2009, on 7 July 2009.
- To support the development of this decree, a manual for providers of distance education was developed, as well as a manual of internal procedures.
- All these documents are available in Portuguese on request from Instituto Nacional de Educação à Distância/National Institute of Distance Education
Practice:
Higher Education
Technical and Vocational Education
General Secondary Education
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/mozambique
Namibia
Policy
Practice
Schooling
- Namibian College of Open Learning: https://namcol.edu.na/
- An institutional OER policy was approved by NAMCOL’s board in 2014.
- An OER policy for the Namibian Open Learning Network Trust (NOLNet) was approved in June 2020.
University
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/namibia
Nigeria
Policy
Practice
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/nigeria
Rwanda
Policy
Practice
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/rwanda
Seychelles
Policy
Practice
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/seychelles
Sierra Leone
Policy
Practice
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/sierra-leone
South Africa
Policy (please also see the discussion in Appendix 2)
Practice
Apart from the University of South Africa, which is a dedicated ODeL institution, many other universities now also offer distance education courses. These are official Distance Education Modes, not the blended flexible learning that all universities have embarked on since the lockdown in March 2020.
Numbers of students enrolled in public HEIs in South Africa, by attendance mode, in 2019.
Institution |
Contact
Total |
Distance
Total |
Cape Peninsula University of Technology |
33,475 |
466 |
University of Cape Town |
28,603 |
38 |
Central University of Technology, Free State |
21,225 |
0 |
Durban University of Technology |
35,442 |
0 |
University of Fort Hare |
16,982 |
0 |
University of the Free State |
37,075 |
4,430 |
University of Johannesburg |
50,064 |
526 |
University of KwaZulu-Natal |
49,512 |
646 |
University of Limpopo |
21,490 |
0 |
Mangosuthu University of Technology |
14,328 |
0 |
University of Mpumalanga |
3,471 |
0 |
Nelson Mandela University |
29,478 |
12 |
North West University |
44,647 |
19,024 |
University of Pretoria |
48,943 |
1,651 |
Rhodes University |
8,247 |
0 |
Sefako Makgatho Health Science University |
6,456 |
0 |
Sol Plaatje University, Northern Cape |
1,994 |
0 |
University of South Africa |
0 |
342,797 |
University of Stellenbosch |
31,523 |
0 |
Tshwane University of Technology |
66,552 |
1,121 |
University of Venda |
16,783 |
0 |
Vaal University of Technology |
21,927 |
0 |
Walter Sisulu University |
33,572 |
0 |
University of Western Cape |
23,784 |
0 |
University of Witwatersrand |
40,710 |
180 |
University of Zululand |
17,738 |
0 |
Totals |
704,021 |
370,891 |
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/south-africa
Tanzania
Policy
Practice
Basic Education/Schooling
- The Institute of Adult Education (IAE): https://www.iae.ac.tz/en
IAE has ODL education programmes starting at the secondary-school level via open schooling and regional centres. IAE also runs ODL programmes at the tertiary level, intended to prepare facilitators and administrators of adult and non-formal education programmes in the local government authority areas. A list of the 151 public open schools and 516 stakeholder-owned open schools affiliated with IAE can be accessed here.
University
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/tanzania
Uganda
Policy
- ICT: National ICT Policy (2014)
Practice
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/uganda
Zambia
Policy
Practice
Schooling
University
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/zambia
Multi-country – Africa
African Council for Distance Education: https://acde-afri.org/
African Virtual University
Distance Education Association of Southern Africa: http://www.deasa.org/
Southern African Development Community
Policy
Practice
Asia
Bangladesh
Policy
Practice
Schooling
University
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/bangladesh
Brunei Darussalam
Policy
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/brunei-darussalam
India
Policy
Practice
Open Schools
Open universities
Dual-mode universities
Name of the University |
State |
Link to the University Site |
Acharya Nagarjuna University (state university) |
Andhra Pradesh |
https://www.nagarjunauniversity.ac.in/indexanu.html |
Sri Krishnadevaraya University, Anantapuramu (state university) |
http://skuniversity.ac.in/
|
Sri Padmavati Mahila Visvavidyalayam (state university) |
https://www.spmvv.ac.in/
|
Rajiv Gandhi University (central university) |
Arunachal Pradesh |
https://rgu.ac.in/
|
Himalayan University, Itanagar (private university) |
https://www.himalayanuniversity.com/
|
Assam Don Bosco University (private university) |
Assam |
https://www.dbuniversity.ac.in/
|
Gauhati University (state university) |
https://www.gauhati.ac.in/
|
Dibrugarh University (state university) |
https://dibru.ac.in/
|
Tezpur University (central university) |
http://www.tezu.ernet.in/
|
Lalit Narayan Mithila University (state university) |
Bihar |
https://lnmu.ac.in/
|
Patna University (state university) |
https://pup.ac.in/
|
Magadh University, Gaya (state university) |
https://www.magadhuniversity.ac.in/
|
Babasaheb Bhimrao Ambedkar Bihar University, Muzaffarpur (state university) |
https://www.brabu.net/
|
Panjab University (state university) |
Chandigarh |
https://www.puchd.ac.in/
|
Chandigarh University (private university) |
https://www.cuchd.in/
|
Dr. C.V. Raman University (private university) |
Chhattisgarh |
https://www.cvru.ac.in/
|
Kalinga University, Raipur (private university) |
https://kalingauniversity.ac.in/
|
Mats University, Raipur (private university) |
https://matsuniversity.ac.in/
|
Jamia Millia Islamia University, Delhi (central university) |
Delhi |
https://www.jmi.ac.in/
|
Indira Gandhi National Open University, Delhi (central university) |
http://www.ignou.ac.in/
|
University of Delhi (central university) |
http://www.du.ac.in/
|
Central Sanskrit University (deemed to be university) |
http://www.sanskrit.nic.in/
|
Jamia Hamdard, New Delhi (deemed to be university) |
http://jamiahamdard.edu/
|
Sabarmati University, Ahmedabad (private university) |
Gujarat |
https://www.sabarmatiuniversity.edu.in/
|
Chaudhary Devi Lal University (state university) |
Haryana |
https://www.cdlu.ac.in/
|
Maharshi Dayanand University (state university) |
https://mdu.ac.in/
|
Guru Jambheshwar University of Science and Technology (state university) |
|
Lingaya’s Vidyapeeth (deemed to be university) |
http://lingayasvidyapeeth.edu.in/
|
Himachal Pradesh University (state university) |
Himachal Pradesh |
https://hpuniv.ac.in/
|
University of Kashmir (state university) |
Jammu & Kashmir |
https://www.kashmiruniversity.net/
|
Mangalore University (state university) |
Karnataka |
https://mangaloreuniversity.ac.in/ |
JSS Academy of Higher Education and Research, Mysuru (deemed to be university) |
https://www.jssuni.edu.in/JSSWeb/WebHome.aspx
|
Manipal Academy of Higher Education, Manipal (private university) |
https://manipal.edu/mu.html
|
Bangalore University (state university) |
https://bangaloreuniversity.ac.in/
|
Kuvempu University (state university) |
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kuvempu_University |
University of Mysore (state university) |
https://uni-mysore.ac.in/
|
Jain University (deemed to be university) |
https://www.jainuniversity.ac.in/
|
University of Kerala (state university) |
Kerala |
https://www.keralauniversity.ac.in/
|
Calicut University (state university) |
https://uoc.ac.in/
|
Kannur University (state university) |
https://kannuruniversity.ac.in/en/
|
University of Mumbai (state university) |
Maharashtra |
https://mu.ac.in/
|
Mahatma Gandhi Antarrashtriya Hindi Vishwa Vidyalaya (central university) |
https://hindivishwa.org/
|
Shivaji University (state university) |
http://www.unishivaji.ac.in/
|
Shreemati Nathibai Damodar Thackersey Women’s University (state university) |
https://sndt.ac.in/
|
DY Patil Vidyapeeth, Mumbai (deemed to be university) |
http://www.dypatil.edu/
|
Kavikulaguru Kalidas Sanskrit University, Nagpur (state university) |
https://kksanskrituni.digitaluniversity.ac/
|
Bharati Vidyapeeth, Pune (deemed to be university) |
|
https://bvuniversity.edu.in/
|
Barkatullah University (state university) |
Madhya Pradesh |
http://www.bubhopal.ac.in/1068/Home
|
Jiwaji University (state university) |
http://www.jiwaji.edu/
|
Maharishi Mahesh Yogi Vedic Vishwavidyalaya (private university) |
http://www.mmyvv.com/
|
Devi Ahilya Vishwavidyalaya (state university) |
https://www.dauniv.ac.in/
|
Mahatma Gandhi Chitrakoot Gramodaya (state university) |
http://gramodayachitrakoot.ac.in/
|
Rabindranath Tagore University, Bhopal (private university) |
https://rntu.ac.in/
|
Amity University, Gwalior (private university) |
https://www.amity.edu/gwalior/
|
Fakir Mohan University (state university) |
Odisha |
http://www.fmuniversity.nic.in/
|
Maharaja Sriram Chandra Bhanja Deo University (State University) |
http://www.nou.nic.in/
|
Punjabi University (state university) |
Punjab |
http://www.punjabiuniversity.ac.in/
|
Lovely Professional University (private university) |
https://www.lpu.in/
|
I.K. Gujral Punjab Technical University, Kapurthala (state university) |
https://ptu.ac.in/
|
Pondicherry University (state university) |
Pondicherry |
https://www.pondiuni.edu.in/
|
Jaipur National University (private university) |
Rajasthan |
https://www.jnujaipur.ac.in/
|
Jain Vishva Bharati Institute (deemed to be university) |
https://jvbi.ac.in/
|
Suresh Gyan Vihar University (private university) |
https://www.gyanvihar.org/
|
Jagannath University (private university) |
https://www.jagannathuniversity.org/
|
Jayoti Vidyapeeth Women’s University (private university) |
https://jvwu.ac.in/index.html |
Amity University, Jaipur (private university) |
https://www.amity.edu/jaipur/
|
JECRC University, Vidhani (private university) |
https://jecrcuniversity.edu.in/
|
University of Madras (state university) |
Tamil Nadu |
https://www.unom.ac.in/
|
Anna University (state university) |
https://www.annauniv.edu/
|
Manomaniam Sundaranar University, Tirunelveli (state university) |
https://www.msuniv.ac.in/
|
Tamil University (state university) |
https://www.tamiluniversity.ac.in/
|
Tamilnadu Physical Education and Sports University (state university) |
https://www.tnpesu.org/
|
Madurai Kamaraj University, Madurai (state university) |
https://mkuniversity.ac.in/
|
Periyar University, Salem (state university) |
https://www.periyaruniversity.ac.in/
|
Shanmugha Arts, Science, Technology & Research Academy, Thanjavur (deemed to be university) |
|
https://www.sastra.edu/
|
Institute of Chartered Financial Analysts of India, Agartala (private university) |
Tripura |
https://www.icfaiuniversity.in/IUTRIPURA/index.html
|
Tripura University (central university) |
https://www.tripurauniv.ac.in/
|
Kakatiya University (state university) |
Telangana |
https://kakatiya.ac.in/
|
Maulana Azad National Urdu University (central university) |
https://manuu.edu.in/home
|
The English and Foreign Languages University (central university) |
https://www.efluniversity.ac.in/
|
Graphic Era University, Dehradun (deemed to be university) |
Uttarakhand |
https://www.geu.ac.in/
|
University of Petroleum and Energy Studies (private university) |
https://www.upes.ac.in/
|
Aligarh Muslim University (central university) |
Uttar Pradesh |
https://www.amu.ac.in/
|
Amity University, Noida (private university) |
https://www.amity.edu/
|
Integral University (private university) |
https://www.iul.ac.in/
|
Swami Vivekanand Subharti University (private university) |
https://www.subharti.org/
|
Dayalbagh Educational Institute (deemed to be university) |
https://www.dei.ac.in/dei/
|
Shri Venkateshwara University (private university) |
https://svu.edu.in/
|
University of Burdwan (state university) |
West Bengal |
https://www.buruniv.ac.in/
|
Vidyasagar University (state university) |
http://www.vidyasagar.ac.in/ |
University of Kalyani (state university) |
https://www.klyuniv.ac.in/ |
Rabindra Bharati University (state university) |
http://www.rbu.ac.in/ |
University of North Bengal (state university) |
https://www.nbu.ac.in/ |
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/india
Malaysia
Policy
Practice
University
Many public universities also share some course material as OER:
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/malaysia
Maldives
Policy
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/maldives
Pakistan
Policy
Practice
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/pakistan
Singapore
Policy
Currently, Singapore does not have any ODL policies or strategies at the government level. Singapore’s autonomous universities — the National University of Singapore (NUS), Nanyang Technological University (NTU), Singapore Management University, Singapore University of Technology and Design, Singapore Institute of Technology and Singapore University of Social Sciences (SUSS) — have autonomy over their curricula, including ODL offerings.
Practice
University
Private education institutions
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/singapore
Sri Lanka
Policy
Practice
University
Other offering distance education
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/sri-lanka
Multi-country – Asia
Policy
Caribbean & the Americas
Antigua and Barbuda
Policy
Practice
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/antigua-and-barbuda
The Bahamas
Practice
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/bahamas
Barbados
Policy
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/barbados
Belize
Policy
See multi-country initiatives
Practice
Schooling
Post-schooling
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/belize
Canada
Practice
Schooling
University
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/canada
Dominica
Policy
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/dominica
Grenada
Policy
Practice
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/grenada
Guyana
Policy
- The government awards scholarships for ODL studies: goal.edu.gy
Practice
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/guyana
Jamaica
Policy
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/jamaica
St Kitts and Nevis
Policy
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/st-kitts-and-nevis
Saint Lucia
Policy
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/saint-lucia
St Vincent and the Grenadines
Policy
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/st-vincent-and-the-grenadines/
Trinidad and Tobago
Policy
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/trinidad-and-tobago
Multi-country – Caribbean & the Americas
Caribbean Regional Policy Framework for Open and Distance Learning: https://caricom.org/documents/9844-caribbean_regional_policy_framework_for_open_and_distance_learning.pdf
ICT strategy: https://caricom.org/ict-for-development-overview/
Caribbean distance education project: Strategies for Distance Education and Training in the Caribbean: A UNESCO, Blackboard and UWI Initiative
Education Sector Plan: Organization of East Caribbean States: https://www.globalpartnership.org/content/education-sector-plan-oecs (see “Priorities,” p. 23)
University of the West Indies, Open Campus: https://www.open.uwi.edu
Europe
Cyprus
Policy
Practice
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/cyprus
Malta
Policy
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/malta
United Kingdom
Policy
Practice (open, dual and mixed mode)
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/united-kingdom
Pacific
Australia
Policy
Practice
Schooling
University
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/australia
Fiji
Practice
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/fiji
Kiribati
Policy
Practice
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/kiribati
Nauru
Policy
Practice
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/nauru
New Zealand
Policy
Practice
Schooling
Post-schooling
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/new-zealand
Papua New Guinea
Policy
Practice
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/papua-new-guinea
Samoa
Policy
Practice
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/samoa
Solomon Islands
Policy
Practice
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/solomon-islands
Tonga
Policy
- ICT: National ICT Policy
- The Tonga Digital Government Strategic Framework document shared by the Director for IT at the Ministry for Meteorology, Energy, Information, Disaster Management, Environment, Climate Change and Communications is also available on request from the ministry.
Practice
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/tonga
Tuvalu
Policy
Practice
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/tuvalu
Vanuatu
Policy
Practice
COL country profile: https://www.col.org/member-countries/vanuatu
Multi-country – Pacific
University of the South Pacific: https://www.usp.ac.fj/
Established in 1968, USP is one of only two universities of its type in the world. It is jointly owned by the governments of 12 member countries: Cook Islands, Fiji, Kiribati, Marshall Islands, Nauru, Niue, Solomon Islands, Tokelau, Tonga, Tuvalu, Vanuatu and Samoa. The university has campuses in all member countries. During the pandemic, USP shifted significantly into ODFL provision.
Virtual University for Small States of the Commonwealth: https://vussc.col.org/
Appendix 1: The evolution of ODL policy and practice in Malaysia
Input from Ministry of Education, Malaysia
Updates on National ODL Policy and Practice in Malaysia
1. ODL policies/strategies
The basic education sector in the past has always focused on classroom delivery, without seriously considering distance learning as a credible mode. With school closure due to the COVID-19 pandemic, teachers needed to quickly adapt to the new form of teaching and learning, and shift teaching and learning from the public space (school classrooms) to a more personal arena (online platforms).
a. Teaching and Learning at Home Manual (PdPR)
The Ministry of Education (MoE) Malaysia developed the Manual Pengajaran dan Pembelajaran di Rumah (PdPR), or the Teaching and Learning at Home Manual, to provide support for teachers dealing with new forms of instruction. This manual offers guidance to teachers to structurally conduct teaching and learning from home. Besides being a reference to allow continuous learning for students, the guide also helps teachers to create a “parent-friendly” teaching and learning environment so that parents can provide ongoing support for their children’s learning activities.
b. Digital Educational Learning Initiatives Malaysia (DELIMa)
The transition from face-to-face instruction to distance learning in Malaysia is facilitated by Digital Educational Learning Initiatives Malaysia (DELIMa), which has been in place since 2019 to integrate digital tools to support online teaching and learning. This platform offers free educational services and applications in a single place and is available to all schools, teachers and students in Malaysia.
c. Komuniti Guru Digital Learning (KGDL)
Komuniti Guru Digital Learning (KGDL), launched in collaboration with MoE Malaysia’s strategic partners, exists to ensure teachers are given the opportunity to acquire knowledge and skills in distance teaching and learning, particularly to help teachers plan, curate and utilise the various online applications suitable for distance learning. To further support teachers, Komuniti Guru Digital Learning has created the Resource Bank KGDL, developed by teachers for teachers as part of MoE Malaysia’s professional learning community.
d. EduwebTV
MoE Malaysia introduced EduwebTV, which hosts on-demand content for students from pre-kindergarten to secondary school. MoE Malaysia also collaborated with broadcasting agencies — Radio Television Malaysia (RTM) and Malaysian satellite TV provider ASTRO — to broadcast educational TV programmes via selected channels, reaching out to as many children as possible in an effort to minimise academic loss as a result of school closures during the pandemic.
e. DidikTV
In addition to the existing EduWebTV, a special terrestrial educational TV channel, DidikTV, was launched on 17 February 2021 to facilitate the home-based teaching and learning (PdPR) processes. From 7 am to 12 midnight daily, DidikTV broadcasts lessons aligned with the national school curriculum.
2. OER policies/strategies
In the context of basic education, the DELIMa platform is in many ways aligned with open educational resources policies, in that access to this platform is provided to all schools at no cost and with very few restrictions for teachers and students.
The DELIMa platform offers all the applications and services required by teachers and students within the Malaysian school system, including technologies that enable digital learning, as well as resources such as Google Classroom, Microsoft Office 365 and Apple Teacher Learning Centre.
DELIMa, accessible at moe-dl.edu.my, was envisioned with the following guiding tenets:
- platform democratisation — digital learning accessible to all, supporting a multi-technology ecosystem;
- lifelong learning — student-centric experiences so learning can take place anytime; and
- digital transformation — MoE Malaysia’s commitment to the country’s future needs.
On average, DELIMa is being utilised by 1.7 million users, with Google Classroom being a prominent application of the digital learning platform.
Appendix 2: The evolution of ODL policy in South Africa
Compiled by Trudi van Wyk
The legislative and policy context in South Africa
Open learning is not a new idea in South Africa. It has its roots in the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996, and there is a strong thread of references to open learning and related concepts in many Acts of Parliament and policies dating back to 1995.
The Department of Higher Education and Training (DHET) derives its ultimate legislative mandate from the Constitution in terms that speak directly to open learning principles:
(1) Everyone has the right
(a) to a basic education, including adult basic education; and
(b) to further education, which the state, through reasonable measures, must make progressively available and accessible.
(2) Everyone has the right to receive education in the official language or languages of their choice in public educational institutions where that education is reasonably practicable. In order to ensure the effective access to, and implementation of, this right, the state must consider all reasonable educational alternatives . . . taking into account
(a) equity;
(b) practicability; and
(c) the need to redress the results of past racially discriminatory laws and practices.
The following are key pieces of legislation regarding education and training:
- The Higher Education Act, 1997 (Act No. 101 of 1997), which regulates higher education, providing inter alia for the establishment of a Council on Higher Education (CHE) and public higher education institutions, the registration of private higher education institutions, and quality assurance and quality promotion in higher education institutions.
- The Continuing Education and Training Act, 2006 (Act No. 16 of 2006) provides for the governance and funding of TVET and CET colleges, the existence of private colleges, and the establishment and functioning of the South African Institute for Vocational and Continuing Education and Training (SAIVCET),
- The General and Further Education and Training Quality Assurance Act, 2001 (Act No. 58 of 2001) (GENFETQA Act) provides for the quality assurance of colleges, both public and private.
- The National Student Financial Aid Scheme Act, 1999 (Act No. 56 of 1999) (NSFAS Act) provides for the management, governance and administration of the National Student Financial Aid Scheme, which grants loans and bursaries to eligible students at public colleges and public universities, thus opening access to thousands of students who would otherwise be deprived of post-school education and/or training.
- The National Qualifications Framework Act, 2008 (Act No. 67 of 2008) (NQF Act) provides for the National Qualifications Framework, as well as the South African Qualifications Authority (SAQA) and the Quality Councils (QCs), the entities on which the regulation of qualifications depend, as well as mechanisms such as the recognition of prior learning (RPL), articulation, and credit accumulation and transfer, all of which contribute to the realisation of more open access to lifelong learning opportunities.
- So too does the Skills Development Act, 1998 (Act No. 97 of 1998), which provides for an integrated framework to devise and implement national, sector and workplace strategies to develop and improve the skills of the South African workforce, and to integrate those strategies within the National Qualifications Framework. It also provides for learnerships that lead to recognised occupational qualifications, and the financing of skills development by means of a levy-financing scheme.
In addition, subordinate legislation and a raft of education-related white papers have established a mandate for open learning in South African post-secondary education and training.
Within the context of higher education and training, the following subordinate pieces of legislation have been developed and published since 2009:
- Under the 1997 Higher Education Act, the Policy for the Provisioning of Distance Education in South Africa Universities in the Context of an Integrated Post-School System (GN 589) was gazetted on 7 July 2014, as was the Policy on Professional Qualifications for Lecturers in Technical and Vocational Education and Training (GN 410) on 11 June 2013. Programmes leading towards some of the latter qualifications have been selected to be among the first piloted on the new National Open Learning System.
- Under the Skills Development Act, 1998 (Act No. 97 of 1998), the establishment of Sector Education and Training Authorities (SETAs) (GN R1055 in GG 33756 of 11 November 2010), and of the Quality Council for Trades and Occupations (QCTO) (GN 247 in GG 33059 of 1 April 2010).
- The White Paper on Education and Training (1995) called for the adoption of open learning principles, and the establishment of a National Open Learning Agency (NOLA) that would “conduct an analysis of the capacity of existing institutions which might form part of the national open learning system.” This white paper affirmed the government’s commitment to opening up learning and removing barriers to education for those who have been disadvantaged by South Africa’s past.
Subsequent policy and planning initiatives have built on this theme:
- The DHET’s Strategic Plan supported and is still supporting the development of open learning opportunities as part of the post-school system, with the intention of connecting education institutions and curricula to emerging networks and information resources, and of promoting innovation and opportunities for lifelong learning.
- White Paper 4: A Programme for the Transformation of Further Education and Training (1998) committed the ministry to the development and expansion of high-quality, flexible, innovative further education and training (now TVET) institutions, based on the principles of open learning and responsiveness to the needs and demands of all learners aged 15 or over. Open learning approaches and a system increasingly orientated towards lifelong learning and responsiveness to the needs of learners and communities would widen participation, promote equity and social mobility, and improve the quality of life of South Africans.
This white paper envisaged:
[an] open learning philosophy and programme-based approach to provision [to] encourage institutional diversity, the use of multiple sites of learning and the growth of “virtual” institutions. Learning will take place in the workplace, at community facilities and in learners’ private homes. Some learners will use the Internet and other technologies to access learning via a “web” or network of providers who might be located very far apart and who need have no formal, centralised organisation or structure. Open learning systems and an integrated approach to education and training will thus allow people to learn what they want, when they want and in the form they want, to satisfy their cultural, spiritual, career, personal development and other needs.
- White Paper 3 on the Transformation of the Higher Education System (2007) promoted the development of a flexible learning system, including distance education and resource-based learning, built on open learning principles. It also mandated expanding the range of programmes to be offered and increasing student enrolments based on open learning and distance education, especially for young and older adults, with particular emphasis on women. Furthermore, this white paper required the then Department of Education to support the development of a national network of centres of innovation in course design and development, as this would enable the creation and franchising of well-designed, quality and cost-effective learning resources and courses, building on the expertise and experience of top-quality scholars and lecturers in different parts of the country.
- The White Paper on e-Education (2007), which addressed eLearning for the school and post-school sectors, saw ICT and eLearning as critically important tools in the struggle against poverty, underdevelopment and marginalisation, and drew attention to the “digital divide” between those with access to ICT and those with little or no access. Developments in ICT would create access to learning opportunities, remove barriers to learning, redress inequalities, improve the quality of learning and teaching, and deliver lifelong learning — all principles of open learning. In addition, this white paper saw e-Education as more than developing computer literacy and the skills needed to operate various types of ICT; it needed to support larger systematic, pedagogical, curricular and assessment reforms that would facilitate improved education and advance higher-order thinking skills. eLearning would not replace teachers but rather would enhance the quality and reach of their teaching if it was thoughtfully selected and integrated into educational planning and management.
- In 2013, the Open Learning in Post School Education and Training Concept Note, prepared by DHET, recognised that open learning should be embedded in, enhance and expand the current education and training system. It focused on the conceptualisation of open learning (OL) and the development of an OL system for post-secondary education and training, as well as presenting the first OL implementation strategy. Later in 2013, the Concept Framework for an Open Learning System in Post-School Education and Training in South Africa, prepared for DHET by the Commonwealth of Learning, further unpacked the concept of OL for the South African context, explored models and examples of OL provision, and described the characteristics of an OL system. The framework also outlined the policy and other implications of creating an enabling environment for OL and crystallised a number of initiatives to be undertaken as a means for piloting prototypes in the process of establishing a workable OL management system on which certain programmes and courses would have a presence.
- In a chapter of the 2014 White Paper for Post-School Education and Training entitled “Open Learning through Diverse Modes of Provision,” DHET commits itself to broadening models of educational provision so that people have easier access to meaningful opportunities throughout their lives. It emphasises the importance of creating networks of providers and learning centres to open up educational opportunities, as well as the necessity for creating an enabling ICT infrastructure.
- DHET’s 2014 Policy for the Provision of Distance Education in South African Universities in the Context of an Integrated Post-School System, though its focus is narrower than open learning for PSET, highlights open access to post-schooling education opportunities for those who cannot attend traditional campus-based provision, the need for quality assurance to ensure that distance education provision offers a reasonable chance of success, and the potential of distance education to lower costs per student by amortising curriculum design, materials development and some teaching costs across larger numbers of students and by obviating the need for continuing investment in physical infrastructure. Among its key provisions are promoting the development and use of open educational resources and creating an enabling environment for the appropriate integration of information and communication technology to enhance education provision in universities and other post-schooling institutions. This policy also includes an undertaking to work towards ensuring that every post-schooling student will have reasonable access to affordable connectivity.
- In the wider national policy context, the Council on Higher Education (CHE) published in 2014 the Distance Higher Education Programmes in a Digital Era: Programme Accreditation Criteria and Good Practice Guide, which makes a significant contribution to our understanding of the implications of using ICT in support of both distance and classroom-based education, and provides clear and detailed guidance in the carefully thought-out choices that course and materials designers must make when employing ICT in support of learning.
- Furthermore, the 2016 Implementation Strategy for Open Learning in the Post-School Education and Training System sets out in some detail the ten strategic outcomes incorporated in the implementation section of the 2014 policy.
- A Draft Policy Framework for the Provision of Open Learning and Distance Education in South African Post-School Education and Training was developed in 2016 and is in the process of being finalised.
- In 2019, DHET initiated the development of a Competency Framework for Lecturer Training and Professional Development in ICT, and the draft will be finalised in 2021.
- In March 2021, the minister approved the Strategy for Expanding Online Learning in Post-School Education and Training: Towards a National Educational Network for Post-School Education and Training.
Appendix 3: Selected COL policy resources
ODL
Corporate Policy: eLearning
Developing a National ODL Policy: An International Perspective
Gender Guidelines for the Sri Lanka Open School System
OER
Collaborative Approach to OER Policy and Guidelines Development in the Commonwealth: The Case of Botswana, Cameroon and Sri Lanka
Corporate Policy: Open Educational Resources
Guidelines on the Development of Open Educational Resources Policies
Institutional OER Policy – Template
OER Policy – Provincial Ministries of Education Sri Lanka
Open Educational Resources: Policy, Costs and Transformation
Towards an Open Educational Resources Strategy for the Republic of Zambia
Policy issues
A Critical Look at Policy Environment for Opening up Public Higher Education in Rwanda
A Guide to Virtual Universities for Policy-Makers
A Policy Brief on MOOCs
Addressing the Learning Needs of Out-of-School Children and Youths through the Expansion of Open Schooling
Analysing Education Policies for the Future: Realising the Vision of Open Distance Learning in 2030
Doctoral Study and Research Degrees: Online and Distance Programmes
Engineering Education: Online and Distance Programmes
From Policy to Practice: Lessons from the Commonwealth
Future Proofing Higher Education in the Pacific with Open and Flexible Learning
Guidelines on Distance Education during COVID-19
Implementing a Blended/Online Learning Policy on a Face-to-Face Campus: Perspectives of Administrators and Implications for Change
Introduction: Policies and Practice (Editorial)
Key Issues in Technology-Enabled Learning: Policy Considerations
Mobile Learning Research: The Focus for Policy-Makers
Policy Brief: Creating New Opportunities for Women and Girls: Enhancing Women’s and Girls’ Success in Technical and Vocational Education
Policy Interventions and Alternative Learning Pathways: Foundation Level Workplace Training Programmes
Quality and Equity in Digital Learning: Policy Brief
Technology-Enabled Learning: Policy, Pedagogy and Practice
The Two Solitudes of Education Policy and the Challenge of Development
Available at: http://hdl.handle.net/11599/3887